Ep 034 Counting Calories vs Counting Macros: Which is Better?
In episode 034 of the Wholly Well Journey podcast, we dive into the debate between counting calories and counting macronutrients for effective weight loss and overall health. We define the nuances of counting calories vs counting macros. After a brief review of definitions of macronutrients, we'll talk about 5 tips on how to count macros. Remember, good nutrition isn't just about quantity, quality matters too!
(You'll also get a brief update on my current personal health and the discovery in Nov 2024 that I have a brain tumor.)
Listeners are guided through practical tips and insights to better understand how these nutritional strategies might fit into their lives and help them meet weight loss, fitness, and general health goals!
If you enjoyed this podcast, please take a second to leave review on one of the following sites:
Subscribe on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and iHeart radio
Stephanie’s Blog & Coaching
Show Timeline
00:00 Introduction to Calorie Counting vs. Macro Counting
00:45 Stephanie's Background and Early Beliefs
01:33 The Evolution of Diet Wisdom
02:44 Intuitive Eating and Mindful Choices
04:38 Personal News (Brain Tumor) and Podcast Anniversary
08:58 The Importance of Tracking Food Intake
09:51 Understanding Macronutrients
19:20 Practical Tips for Counting Macros
23:24 Closing Thoughts and Future Topics
Outline and Show Notes Episode 034
Episode Outline
Introduction to Counting and Weight Loss Myths
Stephanie challenges the myth that weight loss is simply about eating less and moving more.
The importance of understanding the quality of food, not just calorie quantity.
Calorie Counting vs. Macro Counting
Definition and differentiation of calories and macronutrients (proteins, carbohydrates, fats).
Explanation of the flaws of calorie counting alone.
Advantages of macro counting in managing hunger and promoting satiety.
The Role of Intuitive Eating
Reflection on intuitive eating and its significance in maintaining a healthy mindset around food.
Stephanie's Health Journey
Personal story of her diagnosis with a brain tumor and how logging food and macros has helped.
Practical Tips for Counting Macros
Step-by-step guidelines on tracking macros effectively.
Recommendations for tools and apps to facilitate tracking.
Detailed insight into the role of proteins, carbohydrates, and fats in the diet.
Conclusion and Key Takeaways
Encouragement to balance macro intake for optimal metabolic function.
Emphasis on gaining knowledge and experience, and experimenting with dietary tools.
Additional Resources and Closing Remarks
Information about upcoming topics and resources on fasting.
An encouraging note to share the episode and engage with the podcast community.
Podcast Summary
Welcome to another enlightening episode of the Wholly Well Journey podcast. Today, we're diving deep into the longstanding debate between counting calories and counting macros: Which strategy is truly more effective for achieving optimal health?
Breaking Down Weight Loss Myths
The episode begins with a critical look at the commonly held belief that weight loss is just a matter of eating less and moving more. Stephanie Hodges begins by debunking this myth, emphasizing that our bodies are complex systems that require more than just simple arithmetic to manage effectively. As she explains, it's not merely about quantity but quality.
Stephanie’s Journey and Shifts in Perspective
Stephanie brings a personal touch, sharing her past experiences as a group fitness instructor. She elaborates on how her understanding of nutrition has evolved over two decades. The narrative provides listeners with a fresh perspective on why she no longer subscribes to the calorie deficit mantra as the sole path to weight loss.
The Science of Calorie Counting vs. Macro Counting
Moving further into the episode, Stephanie draws a clear distinction between calories and macronutrients (proteins, carbohydrates, and fats). She articulates why counting macros can offer a more holistic and effective way to manage dietary intake, influencing hunger levels and overall well-being beyond just calories alone.
Integrating Intuitive Eating
In a thoughtful segment, Stephanie revisits her previous episode on intuitive eating. She emphasizes the importance of being mindful and intentional with food choices, advocating a balance between intuitive practices and structured nutritional strategies like macro counting.
Personal Health Update
Listeners get a heartfelt update on Stephanie's personal journey as she shares news about a recent health challenge. Diagnosed with a brain tumor, Stephanie shares how this experience has reshaped her approach to nutrition—not as a restrictive measure, but as a journey of awareness and empowerment.
Tips for Macro Tracking Success
For those interested in practical implementation, Stephanie provides a comprehensive guide on getting started with macro counting. From using tracking apps like MyFitnessPal to understanding portion sizes with a food scale, Stephanie offers valuable tips for integrating this practice into daily life effectively.
Understanding Macronutrients
The episode continues with an in-depth exploration of why proteins, carbohydrates, and fats are essential components of a healthy diet. Stephanie highlights the functions and benefits of each macronutrient, encouraging balanced consumption to support metabolic health and overall wellness.
Conclusion and Continuing the Journey
Stephanie wraps up the episode with key takeaways, emphasizing that neither calories nor macros should be demonized. Instead, the focus should be on understanding and experimenting to find what works best for each individual's unique body needs and lifestyle.
Looking Ahead
As we approach a new year, Stephanie offers a sneak peek into future discussions on fasting and her health journey, promising more insights and resources for her listeners. If you've found value in this episode, be sure to share it with others and join us as we continue the journey to becoming wholly well.
For more information and resources, visit Holywelljourney.com and stay connected with the Wholly Well community. As always, this podcast is designed for educational purposes, reminding listeners to consult healthcare professionals before making significant health changes.
We hope you enjoy this enriching dialogue and find inspiration to nourish your body with intention and care.
Leave a review on Apple Podcasts
Subscribe on